Feasibility of developing personalised treatment pathways for relief of plantar heel pain using a sequential multiple assignment randomised trial (SMART) study design.
Background:
The plantar fascia is a thick band of tissue in the bottom of the foot that attaches to the heel bone. Inflammation of the plantar fascia can cause Plantar Heel Pain (PHP). This hurts so much that it limits movement and activities. It is very common - almost 1 in 10 middle-aged or older adults have experienced PHP. Each year, around 1,200 people with PHP are referred to Cardiff and Vale University Health Board (CAVUHB) but the total number of people with PHP across Wales is likely to be many more. This affects the health and wellbeing of our nation and that of the Welsh economy.
Treatments for PHP include exercise advice, shoe insoles, and shockwave (ultrasound) therapy. The aim is to reduce pain and restore function. Each treatment can work better for some people than others. Recovery may be affected by age, weight or activity level. A patient-centred approach adapts treatments to suit individual people's needs. It aims to improve outcomes that matter to people with PHP.
A recent study showed that patients want earlier access to self-help videos. They also wanted information on which treatments are most effective. Research has not proven the best order in which treatments are provided. Without clear guidance this could result in variation in care across Wales.
Aim:
In the long term, we want to work with patients and NHS staff to find out which treatment pathways work best. This small feasibility study will help us to decide if a full-scale trial should go ahead.
Our feasibility study is step 3 in the following sequence: 1) Develop self-help video; 2) Review literature; 3) Single-site feasibility study; 4) Full-scale multicentre trial to test effectiveness; 5) Spread and scale implementation across Wales; 6) Share methods with other departments.
Approach:
Our feasibility study uses a new research design that looks at whole patient pathways instead of separate treatments. We will recruit 50 people referred to CAVUHB with ongoing PHP. They will be allocated at random to one of 4 different treatment pathways (known as adaptive interventions). All treatments are currently available in the NHS. We will collect study data from participants and staff using questionnaires, interviews, and focus groups.
What we hope to discover (objectives):
One of our key outcome measures is whether the tailored treatment pathways are acceptable to patients. Staff will also feed back their views about tailoring the adaptive interventions. We will learn how well our study design works, and how to improve it.
Public involvement:
We are actively partnering with patients and clinicians to co-produce this research proposal. One of our co-applicants leads a team of patient and public involvement (PPI) partners. Four people with lived experience of PHP and a retired podiatrist helped to develop our PPI partnership plan.
They've also advised on outcomes that matter most to patients.
Sharing our findings:
We will use our website, social media, and a newsletter to keep people up to date. At the end of the project, we will host a stakeholder feedback event where we will discuss what the results mean for our patients and for podiatry services in Wales. PPI partners will help to share our findings to the public. Other NHS staff and researchers may also want to adopt our methods to improve other clinical pathways in the future. We will share our findings with NHS networks, publish in an academic journal, and present at conferences.